Work note

Why recognition and experience must not become habit

Why recognition and experience must not become habit

A plea against laziness. And no, I don't mean Onslow. 😉

You can work hard yet think lazily. Doing the same thing ever more smoothly, for example, without asking yourself whether it is the right answer for the customer and/or for that situation.

That is quite an uncomfortable thought, especially once you have been around for a while and quite rightly consider your experience an advantage.

To be clear: I have no intention of giving up that experience. It helps me see connections, recognise possibilities and arrive at a first idea more quickly; those habits help too, and you don't have to start from scratch every working day.

It gets interesting the moment recognition takes the place of inquiry.

I mean it as in "This looks like something I know. So the same approach will fit." That is exactly where I want to keep catching myself!

First, notice something

At SSA Archery we walk through a "hidden" door, towards the room where product photos are taken. Daan has something to show: the renewed AVALON Cam & String Protector, for example. He fits the protector, clicks it into place and even carries the bow with it.

In the accompanying text, that door gets its place. As does a small wink to Walter, who was in the United Kingdom at the time.

That is precisely the kind of moment that appeals to me. There are people, a product and an action that makes something clear. There is a story in that, I think.

That first idea does not always arise in neatly planned steps. Sometimes I see the opening before I can explain exactly why it appeals to me. Sometimes one remark connects with another question I am working on.

I deliberately want to leave room for that. If every thought immediately has to be a fully substantiated proposal, you scrap quite a few possibilities before you have been able to explore (or rather: imagine) which direction you can take with them.

Experience helps me get started somewhere. It does not yet determine where I should end up. And neither should it!

A wink has to be able to carry something

In the AVALON video, humour and product information sit side by side. Daan shows the actions. The text names the protection against knocks and dirt, the fastening and carrying the bow with the protector in place.

Even someone who does not know Walter must be able to understand what is being shown.

That is where the focused thinking begins. Does the opening fit the video? Does the explanation match the demonstration? Is something missing that is self-evident to us, but not to a viewer?

A joke may claim attention as long as what follows is what that attention was worth.

In Kahneman's distinction between fast, intuitive thinking and more conscious thinking that takes effort, I recognise something of that movement. An angle presents itself; then it asks for inquiry. It is a useful comparison, not a manual with two switches. If only it were that obvious...

And (too) long thinking offers no guarantee either. You can become quite thorough in defending an idea you have meanwhile grown just a little too fond of.

A question must therefore also be allowed to produce an unwanted answer. Otherwise it is mostly an approval dressed up as research.

Sometimes someone just asks for daylight

Via ASK SSA came the question what the Chameleon finish of a KINETIC riser looks like in daylight. Walter took one outside. By a bench near the warehouses he turned that handle in all directions (and my camera moved along), so that colour and gloss became visible from different angles.

The question came from someone else. Walter did the demonstration. The material already existed as a story and was later also turned into a reel with accompanying text. Someone wanted to be able to judge something. The image provided information for that.

A dealer can use such a clip when the same question comes back. Whether that actually happens has to become apparent from use or reactions. Seeing an application is not the same as knowing it is being used. And it is precisely that difference that also determines what I can learn from it. When I only look at the work that was made, I still don't know what someone did with it.

For this question, a hidden door has little to add. Daylight does.

Routine is useful. Until it starts deciding for you.

By doing work more often, you get better at it. You recognise a usable moment more quickly, know which information you need and find a form more easily. That frees up time and attention. You don't have to re-examine everything you already know well enough.

But familiarity can also become a comfortable argument. A familiar opening. The same structure. A way of working everyone has mastered.

You can get steadily better at that with great dedication, while the question of whether that approach still fits quietly fades into the background.

That is the laziness I am talking about. It can disguise itself perfectly as busyness.

Kenneth Arrow described how knowledge arises in the course of doing work. He also pointed out that the learning effect diminishes when you keep solving essentially the same problem. James March examined the tension between refining existing ways of working and exploring new possibilities.

In that I see a practical question for my own work: am I only getting better at carrying out the assignment, or do I keep checking whether the assignment is still the right one?

Editing the next video better is one exercise. Checking whether a video is the appropriate answer asks for a different view: perhaps product information is missing, or someone wants to be able to compare. Perhaps the difficulty lies in daily operations and extra communication only helps to a limited extent.

That too must remain a possible outcome when the requested execution fits my experience perfectly.

"New" is no argument in itself either

The same test applies to new possibilities. They catch my attention. I enjoy exploring a path I suspect could mean something for a customer or for one of my own projects.

And sometimes I quickly see where it fits, but just as often I first have to try something to understand it. What matters in that: I don't need to know every step in advance. I very much don't want to! But I do want to be able to explain why the inquiry is worthwhile. Which problem does it touch? For whom could it change something? What does it ask of the people who have to work with it?

And during that inquiry the plan may shift. A new possibility can reveal that the original question was too narrow, or that a simpler solution will do.

Always wanting to do something new can, by the way, become a habit just as well. Then you replace the familiar answer with the newest answer, without looking at the question more closely. That is of little use to a customer.

My first idea gets to come along

I want to be able to trust what I have learned, without forcing every new case into it.

For that I need both: the speed with which something strikes me and the attention to examine what it is worth. Sometimes that examination confirms the first idea. Sometimes the execution changes. Sometimes something else has to happen.

At SSA that takes very ordinary forms. Picking up a product. Listening to a question. Letting someone show something. Writing a text to go with images. And continuing to check what that whole is actually meant to serve.

Because, let's be honest, the point is not to make every decision complicated. It is to prevent convenience (read: laziness) from quietly setting the direction. So my first idea gets a seat at the table. It just doesn't automatically get to be right.

And the next video doesn't have to go through that hidden door again. After all, it has hinges. Not a content contract... 😁

Research

These sources offer language and research for thinking about the way of working described. The connections with my own work are my own interpretation; the examples are not a scientific test of those theories.

Daniel Kahneman — Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011)
About fast, automatic thinking and more conscious thinking that demands attention and effort. The parallel lies in the difference between an angle that presents itself and the focused inquiry that can follow it. Slower thinking is no automatic guarantee of a correct judgement.
Book and excerpt at the publisher

Daniel Kahneman & Gary Klein — Conditions for Intuitive Expertise: A Failure to Disagree (2009)
When does intuition deserve trust? The authors point to sufficiently predictable conditions and the opportunity to learn to recognise the regularities in them. Familiarity and self-confidence alone prove no expert judgement.
Article — American Psychologist, 64(6), 515–526

Kenneth J. Arrow — The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing (1962)
About knowledge that arises in the course of working and solving problems. Arrow also names the diminishing learning effect of repeating the same problem. The parallel: learning to execute better while continuing to examine which new questions deserve attention.
Article — The Review of Economic Studies, 29(3), 155–173

James G. March — Footnotes to Organizational Change (1981)
About change arising from ordinary activities and responses to a complex environment, sometimes with unexpected consequences. The parallel lies in leaving room for what presents itself during the work, without retrospectively presenting every surprise as a strategy devised in advance.
Article — Administrative Science Quarterly, 26(4), 563–577

James G. March — Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning (1991)
About the tension between exploiting existing knowledge and ways of working and exploring new possibilities. The parallel: refining what you have mastered must leave enough room to discover what will be needed tomorrow.
Article — Organization Science, 2(1), 71–87

← Work